Questions about competitions

puzzled cat.pngThere’s been a fair amount of buzz about what competitions are for going on both on-line and here in Montreal.  Lydia at Definitely the Opera raised the question in comments and it came up in conversation at the Salle Bourgie a couple of times last night.  I suppose the basic question is are competitions a way for younger, less well known, singers to get notice, attract an agent etc or are they a way for more established young singers to cement their reputation (and maybe make some money)?  It’s a reasonable thing to ask because it’s asking a lot to expect a 25 year old in a young artists program to compete with a thirty something who has sung significant roles on major stages.

Both types of singer are evident in Montreal this week.  The singers range in age from 24 to 35 with a median age of 29.5.  Experience ranges from “left the conservatory last year” to “has sung at the Met”.  It really stands out in the hall too.  There’s a world of difference between an established and polished performer like John Brancy or Rihab Chaieb and someone new to the limelight like Olga Rudyk.  (The frighteningly mature and confident Emily D’Angelo being the exception that proves the rule!).

It’s also been suggested that there is almost becoming something of a competition “circuit”.  Many of the CMIM competitors (and judges) also featured at the last Wigmore Hall competition.  It’s an interesting thought, especially for art song.  Maybe a competition format would drum up more interest than conventional recitals (though rules severely restricting the use of certain songs would surely be necessary).

As promised, thoughts on art song recitals

gerhaherhuberThe imminent death of the art song recital is perhaps an even more prevalent trope than “opera is dying” doomandgloomery.  It reached something of a crescendo in Toronto when the Aldeburgh Connection shut up shop after thirty years.  Oddly enough there still seem to be plenty of recitals of various kinds but unquestionably there has been something of a shift away from “two dudes in tails with a piano”.

Continue reading