Thinking about Dido and Aeneas

didoflagstadPurcell’s Dido and Aeneas has a long and dense history in the recording studio.  The first recording dates back to 1935 and the vast stream of recordings since serve as a kind of barometer of the changes in style in performing 17th century music.  I haven’t listened to every recording but I can look at four key moments in the discography and compare them.  I’ve also listened or watched a fair number of fairly recent productions.  The video review page has six entries for this work; all 1995 or later.  There are also five reviews of live productions and reviews of several related shows.  But for the purposes of this mini-project I’m going to look at four recordings that take us from the early 1950s to the mid 1990s.  The four recordings are:

  • The 1951 (or 1952 depending on source) EMI recording with Kirsten Flagstad and Elisabeth Schwarzkopf.
  • The 1961 recording with Janet Baker
  • Andrew  Parrott’s seminal 1981 recording with Emma Kirkby
  • Tafelmusik’s 1995 recording

This post will deal with the first with subsequent posts on the others. Continue reading

Pierre and Natasha

Musical theatre is not usually my thing but given the consistently high standard of everything at Crow’s theatre in the last couple of years I was prepared to take a punt on Dave Malloy’s Pierre, Natasha and the Great Comet of 1812 despite knowing full well it was a Broadway musical.  The bottom line is I found it a very odd experience.  There was plenty to like and I kind of get why people like shows like it but It’s still really not my thing but I don’t think I’m the target audience.

GreatComet-photobyDahliaKatz-5898

Continue reading

Titration

TitrationTitration is a song cycle for unaccompanied choir by American composer Shara Nova.  On the CD it is performed by The Crossing and their conductor Donald Nally.  It’s an interesting and unusual, indeed quite unconventional, piece but it is oddly compelling and has won a fair bit of recognition including a Gramophone “Critics Choice” award this year.

It’s rooted in Nova’s reaction to her conservative upbringing in the American South and perhaps the key line of the text is “How do I keep on feeling in this mean, mean world?”  The cycle is ung continuously.  There’s no break between “movements”.  It’s what I can best describe as “post-modern polyphony”.  The interweaving vocal lines are essentially tonal but there’s a good deal of use of extended vocal technique; speech, humming, shouting, laughing, grunting, whooping and even growling and spitting.  All this around a text which is as much about textures and patterns as explicit meaning.

Continue reading

January 2024

jan2024Here’s a look at the start of 2024 in Toronto.

On the 7th and the 9th OPUS chamber music, who feature some of Canada’s best young chamber musicians, have a pair of concerts.  The first is at Trinity St. Paul’s and features music by Rebecca Clarke, Leo Weiner, Anton Webern and Robert Schumann.  The second is at the Arts and Letters Club and includes music by Tcherepini, Klein, Wegener and Beethoven.

Continue reading

Christmas Carol at Campbell House

Where better in Toronto to do a site specific version of Dickens’ A Christmas Carol than Campbell House (built 1822)?  Apparently The Three Ships Collective and Soup Can Theatre have been doing such a show for five years but it had never appeared on my radar until this year despite having seen and enjoyed other Soup Can shows.  So last night I went.

Christmas Carol 2023 by LD 9 Continue reading

Soggy Songs of the Sea

brynseasongsI have to say that I was unreasonably excited to learn about a new CD from Bryn Terfel called Songs of the Sea.  I’ve seen Bryn in recital and, besides being a fantastic singer, he’s a big personality and very good when he steps away from classic art song rep and especially when he sings in Welsh.  There were also some interesting collaborators on the disk; Simon Keenleyside, Calan, Sting and Fisherman’s Friends for example.  Plus there were some interesting language choices.  Besides English and Welsh there are songs in Breton and Norn. Continue reading

TSO Messiah

This year’s Messiah at the TSO is a fairly small scale affair by TSO standards.  There’s still the 100+ strong Toronto Mendelssohn Choir but the orchestra is quite small; 12 violins, 6 violas, 4 cellos, 2 basses, 2 oboes and bassoon, plus Christopher Bagan on a sort of monster harpsichord/organ combo. There were two trumpets in the gallery for “Glory to God” and they were back (on stage) with timpani for the Hallelujah chorus and part 3.  With Jane Glover conducting it felt like it was almost in Tafelmusik territory.

TSO Messiah 5 - Photo by Allan Cabral

Continue reading

Another listen to Owen Wingrave

owenwingraveBritten’s Owen Wingrave is a curiously neglected opera.  It’s rarely performed live and the only recorded versions are 2 CD recordings plus DVDs of TV productions.  The earliest of each feature Benjamin Luxon in the title role and Peter Pears as General Wingrave.  The DVD version holds up surprisingly well for a 1970 TV production.  The later DVD version is also over 20 years old and features Gerald Finley in a, to my mind, ill conceived production for Channel 4 updated to the 1950s.  So I was interested to get my hands on a 2008 Chandos recording with Peter Coleman-Wright as Owen.

Continue reading

Winter Celebrations

DI-08628My usual reaction to holiday season concerts is (polite version) “Bah humbug”.  The less polite version involves reindeer placement.  That said Thursday’s concert from the COC Ensemble Studio was really rather enjoyable.

It opened with Brian Cho and Mattia Senesi doing a four hands version of “Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy”.  Regrettably they didn’t dance.  I guess Korin Thomas-Smith could have filled that role as later in the day he showed some very cool moves but that’s another story.

There was Handel of course; Queen Hezumuryango with “O Thou that Tellest Good Tidings to Zion” and Wesley Harrison with “Ev’ry Valley”.  Both of those featured later in the day too.  But that’s another story.

Continue reading

Hallelujah! x 8

The eighth iteration of Soundstreams’ Electric Messiah opened last night at Theatre Passe Muraille.  Like last year at Crow’s it’s staged fairly conventionally with the players facing the audience though some use was made of the galleries at TPM.  I do kind of miss the club atmosphere of the earliest versions but it still has lots to offer.

Electric Messiah 2023/ Soundstreams

Continue reading