Three card trick

Tchaikovsky’s Queen of Spades is a rather odd opera.  It’s got some really good music but it’s dramatically a bit of a mess; it’s episodic and the plot contains highly implausible occult elements.  The 2016 production at Dutch National Opera was given to Stefan Herheim to direct which is what piqued my interest.  There are few directors as capable of applying some radical rethinking to an opera and coming up with something fully coherent.  I think he manages it here.


It’s a very complex production and unpacking it in detail on a single watching would be near impossible, as well as spoiling the fun for anyone else so what I’ll do is lay out the elements that Herheim uses without trying fully to elaborate how he combines them.

  • He introduces the composer himself as a non-singing character.  He’s clearly towards the end of his life and in a prologue that precedes the overture we see not so subtle hints of an erotic relationship with Hermann and the cholera infused glass of water with which Tchaikovsky is said to have taken his life.
  • The homoerotic element persists but it’s not just Tchaikovsky/Hermann somehow both Liza and the Old Countess (and even the Tsarina) get pulled into this.
  • All four of those characters, plus Yeletsky, appear at one point or another dressed (only) in the composer’s unbuttoned stiff shirt and undone tie.
  • The cholera water keeps on being referenced.  It’s the poison the Old Countess takes when confronted by Hermann.  It’s poured on Liza by the chorus where, canonically, she throws herself in the Neva.
  • The composer’s music paper and piano are also important.  The former serves many roles; notably as the cards in the final scene, while his piano becomes the Old Countess’ coffin.
  • There’s also some more identity confusion.  The male chorus appears dressed and coiffed as the composer on occasions and Yeletsky and the composer are also weirdly similar.
  • Finally, the occult elements are quite ambiguous.  Are they “real”?  Or the figments of Hermann’s imagination?  Or artefacts of the composer’s obsession?


The various ways in which these elements are combined is quite disturbing and thought provoking and also allows for some striking stage pictures.  Set with a vaguely 18th/19th century aesthetic (I can’t pin it down more precisely than that) it’s all rather handsome and sometimes visually quite exciting.  And, in a weird way, it does all make sense though it’s a long way from Pushkin.


Musically it’s really good.  DNO assembled an essentially all Slavic cast of very high quality.  There’s some really fine singing from Misha Didyk as Hermann and, especially, Svetlana Aksenova as Liza.  Her duet with Polina (Anna Goryachova) is gorgeous.  Vladimir Stoyanov is a very distinguished Yeletsky and veteran Larissa Diadkova sounds appropriately mature but not worn as the Old Countess.  The supporting roles are all fine.  The acting is all quite distinguished too though Christiaan Kuyvenhoven as the composer rather steals the show in that department.


Mariss Jansons conducts the Royal Concertgebouw in a highly detailed, dramatic and cogent account of the score.  There’s some particularly fine playing from the strings.  It’s really quite distinguished music making.  The chorus, which has a lot to do, too is excellent both dramatically and musically.


Misjel Vermeiren’s video direction is pretty decent though it’s a big, often busy, stage and there were times when I wanted to see more of the action.  He’s helped by a very good picture, even in the darker scenes, on Blu-ray.  This is one I suspect would not look so good on standard DVD.  The DTS-HD-MA sound is exceptionally clear and detailed and has a natural balance rather than the common tendency to over-project the voices.


The only extras on the disk are a few trailers but the (very) short essay in the booklet does tee things up quite well.  There’s also a synopsis and a detailed track listing.  Subtitles options are English, French, German, Korean and Japanese (but not Russian or Dutch!).


This disk is a success on many levels and is well worth a look for anyone interested in this relatively obscure (outside the former USSR) Tchaikovsky piece.


7 thoughts on “Three card trick

  1. Pique Dame is hardly an obscure opera, we saw many productions here in The Netherlands and I saw the opera in Vienna, Berlin, Paris, New York and in many smaller theaters in Germany. It is a powerful work, grand and intimate at the same time with strong roles for singers who are also good actors. I have visited St. Petersburg and the locations of the opera are all there: the park, the palace of the Countess (Puskin based her on a real aristocrat), the bridge at the Winter Canal.

  2. Pingback: Pique Dame in Salzburg | operaramblings

  3. Thanks! Could you start with pictures of the DVD you are reviewing or by providing identifying details? It takes a while to know which specific recording you are reviewing otherwise. 🙂

    • A while ago I started adding the catalogue number at the end of the review so it will be there going forward. I can’t see me going back over nearly 600 reviews t add it to the older ones though.

      • SO, which of the two recent Pique Dame DVDs would you recommend buying? The Amsterdam or the Salzburg one? The draw to the Salzburg one for me is Brandon Jovanovich.

      • That’s an impossible call. They are both good but very different. Even their weaknesses (the difficulty of filming a large, busy, dark stage) are similar. If you have a taste for Jovanovich go with that one. I don’t think you will be disappointed.

  4. Pingback: Wagner’s Ring at the Deutsche Oper Berlin | operaramblings

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s