Fall River – world premiere

To commemorate the 80th anniversary of the opera programme at UoT, the Opera Division commissioned a new opera from Cecilia Livingston and Michael Patrick Albano. That opera, Fall River, the legend of Lizzie Borden, had its world premiere at The Elgin Theatre on Thursday evening in a UoT Opera production directed by the librettist.

Brooke Zarubin & Lucas White

Michael Patrick has a long standing interest in (obsession with?) turning the Lizzie Borden story into an opera and now it’s come to pass. It’s quite an in depth take on a story about which most people only know a two line nursery rhyme. It gets the atmosphere and moral tone of a small New England town in the 1890s pretty much spot on. It’s claustrophobic and obsessed with a narrow respectability. The intense dislike between Andrew Borden’s adult daughters and his second wife is palpable and rooted in financial insecurity as well as fairly standard daughter/step-mother tropes. The reluctance of the jurors at Lizzie’s trial to believe that a respectable middle class woman could commit a brutal axe murder is very well conveyed. All up, it’s a well crafted libretto which makes intelligent use of the chorus and has a bit of a surprise ending which you can judge for yourself.

Sloane Ryan & Delaney Dam

It’s scored for a fifteen piece ensemble that is almost identical to the line up Britten used in his chamber operas though I don’t recall him including trombone which appears here as a sort of leitmotif for the step-mother Abby. That’s partnered with the use of bassoon for Andrew which probably sums up their relationship with each other and the daughters. It’s a colourful, atmospheric score with plenty of singable music and some really interesting twists. The hymn sung at Abby and Andrew’s graveside (which is weird in itself) morphs into something much stranger and more sinister and there are many such moments. One can hear nods to the opera greats of the 20th century in the music but it’s very much a 21st century work.

Sloane Ryan

The production is mostly straightforward. There’s a single set; the interior of the Borden house, which with a few dust covers and so on also serves as the graveyard and as an all purpose rostrum for minor characters to pronounce their commentary on the action; especially around Lizzie’s trial. Costumes too are realistic for the period. Projections of newspaper headlines about the trial are used to good effect. It’s not flashy but it works.

Mia Robles & Josh Gibson,

There are some very good performances. I especially liked Sloane Ryan as Lizzie. It’s a sympathetic portrayal and she sings well. She even got a chance to show off some impressive coloratura. Mia Robles makes the most of Abby. She oozes a kind of acidic malice. It’s really good acting and she is also vocally quite secure. Josh Gibson is very solid, in all respects, as Andrew. He sings powerfully and accurately and just gives off that “I’m the all knowing (and very important) patriarch” vibe. That’s a bit of a thread this week! Delaney Dam as the elder daughter Emma and Brooke Zarubin as the Irish maid Bridget also acquit themselves well. There are a couple of interesting make cameo roles; Luca McCauley is quite mysterious as Andrew’s brother-in-law John and Christian Matta gives a lyrical performance as Lizzie’s French love interest. The raft of minor characters all get the job done and the chorus, which has a lot to do, especially in the second act, is excellent.

The small orchestra is very good indeed. Being the solo trombonist in a fifteen piece band is pretty exposed but Owen Engstrom does the job well, as does the equally exposed Alice Dix on bassoon. There’s an excellent contribution on the oboe, from Clara Aristanto, too. Jon Bilek and Chris Wong on percussion have a lot to do too and do it well. Sandra Horst conducts and keeps everything co-ordinated and nicely paced. Overall, musically and dramatically this is all rather good and very few allowances need to be made for it being a student performance.

There are three more performances until November 22nd with a slightly different cast tonight and on Sunday.

Photo credit: Hugh Lu

Leave a Reply