Campy Clemenza

1.sestovitelliaBesides the production of La Clemenza di Tito still in repertory at the Met, Jean-Pierre Ponelle also made a film of the piece.  It was shot among the ruins of ancient Rome in 1980 and is one of those lip synched opera films popular in that era.  The forces involved are eclectic.  James Levine conducts the Wiener Philharmoniker and the Konzertvereinigung Wiener Staatsopernchor with mainly American soloists. 

2.ruinIt’s a bit like the Met production in that we have a sort of fantasy 18th century meets a fantasy Ancient Rome but in detail it’s not at all the same.  Partly this is the characterisation.  Most of it is rather overdone.  Eric Tappy’s Tito is practically foaming at the mouth, a lot of recitative is snarled rather than sung and Carol Neblett’s Vitellia can’t make up her mind whether she’s the Queen of the Night or a Disney princess.  A lot of the details are a bit campy too.  Sesto’s cell in Act 2 has chains he(she) could crawl through they are so large.  There are extreme wigs.

3.titoThat said, some of the music making is rather good.  Tatiana Troyanos sings Sesto very well though I find her acting mannered and she’s too old for the part.  Kurt Rydl is a solid Publio and a very young Catherine Malfitano makes an appealing Servilia.  I’m less convinced about Anne Howell’s rather squeaky Annio.  Levine is generally quite fast but he’s precise and dramatic.  I liked it more than some other Levine Mozart efforts.  There are also some arresting visual images with Ponelle using his trademark strong verticals and not afraid to offer broad vistas either.

4.statueTechnical quality is OK.  The picture is 4:3 and 1980s TV quality.  Both LPCM stereo and (reprocessed) DTS surround sound are quite good.  Documentation is standard and there are English, French, German, Spanish, Italian and Chinese subtitles.

In the last analysis I really can’t get too enthused about this.  I’d say anyone interested in the Ponelle aesthetic or a traditional Clemenza would be well advised to wait for the DVD of the recent HD broadcast from the Met which was very good indeed.  If you are interested in versions that explore the work more deeply both the Paris and Salzburg productions can be recommended.

5 thoughts on “Campy Clemenza

  1. Ha, coincidentally this is the latest DVD I watched, after getting very enthusiastic about Clemenza following the Met broadcast which finally made its way to NZ. What is going on here with Tito? He permanently looks like a rabbit that’s just seen a fox. Michael Schade does bonkers much more subtly in the Salzburg version. But yes, seeing Troyanos again reminded just why she was one of my favourite singers in the eighties.

    • I really don’t like this take on Tito. Schade is brilliant in the Salzburg production. Just the right sort of nuts. He was equally good, in a slightly different way, in Christopher Alden’s production in Toronto last month, though he missed half the run with flu.

      • Schade is definitely my favorite bonkers Tito.

        But this whole Ponnelle production . . . ye gods those wigs. I mean, yeah, it was 1980, but still.

      • I think you’ll find 1980 and Ponnelle were a chicken and egg thing when it came to period hair.

  2. Pingback: For pity’s sake | operaramblings

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s