Claus Guth’s 2008 Salzburg production of Don Giovanni divided the critics along entirely predictable lines. It’s a very unusual treatment of Don Giovanni but the concept is stuck to with real consistency and it works to create a compelling piece of music theatre. The treatment on video too is not straightforward and, in a sense, the DVD/Blu-ray version is as much the work of Brian Large as it is of Claus Guth.
The entire piece is set in a forest and uses a revolving stage. There’s a bus shelter and a car and one or two other things but mostly it’s one of those claustrophobic northern pine forests. It’s set in the present and Don Giovanni and Leporello are both intravenous drug users. The Donnas and Don Ottavio are considerably more upscale with expensive clothes and plenty of jewelry. The wedding party is just that though considerable amounts of drink can be assumed.
The central conceit of the piece is that Don Giovanni is fatally wounded in his fight with the Commendatore and is dying for 95% of the opera, only keeping going by shooting up at intervals. Since Leporello is similarly chemically enhanced the border between reality and their imaginations is considerably blurred. There are a number of other interesting interpretations. Donna Anna is clearly seriously attracted to Don Giovanni throughout. The first scene is the most “not a rape” version that I have seen unless tearing a guys shirt off and jumping on top of him constitutes being raped. She’s still at it at the end when she sings Non mi dir to Don Giovanni rather than Don Ottavio before stripping off her finery and running off with Don Ottavio’s pistol; presumably to shoot herself.
Zerlina too is much more forceful than usual. The second act duet with Leporello Per queste tue manine is included and provides an opportunity for Zerlina to beat up Leporello and leave him tied up with a noose round his neck. In her scenes with Masetto she takes “topping from the bottom” to heights unusual even for a Regie Zerlina. We also get a Don Ottavio with more character than usual, showing a fair amount of real irritation with Donna Anna’s prevarications. For the record, the final “redemptive” ensemble scene is omitted.
The performances are of a piece with the production concept. This is not, perhaps, singing for the Mozart purist except for Dorothea Röschmann’s elegantly sung Donna Elvira. Chris Maltman (Don Giovanni) and Erwin Schrott (Leporello) act magnificently and sing their big numbers well enough though perhaps not in the highest Mozartian style. In between the recits are barely sung but they are articulated as one might expect a dying stoned thug to articulate them. Also, Schrott’s impression of a twitching junkie is amazing. Something similar could be said for Annette Dasch’s Donna Anna and Matthew Polenzani’s Don Ottavio. They sing well enough but where there is a trade off between musical and dramatic values the drama wins out every time. They also look pretty good. If any of this suggests Röschmann’s acting is not also of the highest standard be reassured that it is. On occasion I’ve been fairly unimpressed with Röschmann’s acting skills but here she’s very good indeed. Ekaterina Siurina is the best Zerlina I’ve seen. She’s got a lovely voice and she can act. I predict great things from her. Alex Esposito pulls off a Masetto who’s almost as twitchy as Leporello. Anatoli Kotscherga is fairly unmemorable either way as the Commendatore whose role is rather diminished by this production. Bertrand de Billy and the Wiener Philharmoniker sounded fine to me.
As I said earlier the video direction on this one is problematic. Because the stage is rotating and the camera are kept in close it’s all but impossible to tell what angle Large is using and whether or not it’s the same as the theatre audience is seeing. I think it works quite well as a film but it’s not, I think, a very faithful reproduction of the stage production. I would really like to have a better idea of what the audience saw. The picture on Blu-ray manged to cope very well with the generally low light levels and both the DTS Master Audio and PCM stereo soundtracks are high standard. There are no extras and the documentation is not especially enlightening. There are English, French, German, Italian and Chinese subtitles.
Don Giovanni is one of those operas that just keeps on giving. Anyone interested in exploring its many possibilities should get plenty out of this disk.
You finally got to see it! This is one of my favorite Don Giovannis – it’s appropriately dark, but there are these flashes of bizarre humor to it as well. (And I also really enjoyed Schrott’s junkie impression.)
I could stand to see more of many of the singers in this production. I could certainly stand to see a lot more of Annette Dasch!
Here is Annette Dasch eingspringing into the la Scala Lohengrin: http://vimeo.com/55201806
Thanks! I took a quick look. I think I’d find the Neuenfels Lohengrin easier to watch. She’s lovely in both though. Its those “deer in the headlights” eyes.
Oh my world, I was just finishing reading this post when I saw your comment on my blog. Thanks by the way, I’ll look the interview up! You know I’ve always wanted to watch this production but never got to, maybe one day I’ll be able to buy this dvd! It’s hard to buy these things here in Brasil. I looooove Dorothea, I think she’s stellar as Donna Elvira (which is my favorite female in this opera) and Erwin is just hilarious as Leporello!
I buy most of my DVDs from the UK. Better prices than here in Canada! I saw your comment on The Earworm and went over for a look. I want Anna and Erwin over for dinner. I think they’d be a blast.
Just listened to the podcast with Camila, and yeah, it’s real hard path to go for here in Brasil, there are next to zero opportunities. But thank you so much for pointing it out for me, it gives me hope! 😀 But here we all know that if we want to thrive in this business we need to study abroad. Otherwise we’ll be in choruses forever.
But aren’t they one of the cutest and nicest opera couples ever? I love them! I’ll be lucky enough to watch them at the Met in February in Elisir that I’m super exited about. It’s going to be my first time watching opera in a big big opera house. Maybe take a picture, cry a lot definitely. 😀
Enjoy it. I’ve never been to the Met but I live and work within walking distance of the Four Seasons Centre in Toronto so I can’t complain.
Must watch this version again… its been ages! The one thing I remember really liking about it was the vivid love/hate relationship between the Don and Leporello. There’s something touching about seeing Leporello tend to his obviously-dying master’s wound, not to mention his tears in the final scene as the Don meets his fate. I guess I’m a sucker for Tragic Bromance.
It surprises me how rarely directors look into the relationship between Leporello and Don Giovanni. Virtually every other potential/actual pairing has been looked at in almost every possible way. One for fanfic perhaps?
Opera fanfic . . . I’m not sure whether to shudder or feel curious!
Just think of the crossover and slash possibilities… or don’t!
Speaking of Maltman, has anyone seen the Kasper Holten thing?
I don’t think it has shown here yet
Yeah, I don’t imagine it will at this late date, but thought someone might have scored the DVD or found it posted up somewhere. I guess Amazon UK has it but Amazon US still doesn’t (officially).
Presto has it at a decent price
Pingback: Happy families | operaramblings
Pingback: A Mountain of Mozart | operaramblings
Pingback: A new Salzburg da Ponte cycle – Così fan tutte | operaramblings
Pingback: Bechtolf Round Two – Don Giovanni | operaramblings
Reblogged this on Alfred Eaker's The BlueMahler and commented:
A spot on review of Claus Guth’s staging of “Don Giovanni.”